Retspraksis

  • Sagsoplysninger
    • Nationalt ID-nr.: H.D. 288/2009 and 289/2009 (or U 2012.1089H)
    • Medlemsstat: Danmark
    • Almindeligt anvendt navn:H.D. 288/2009 and 289/2009 (or U 2012.1089H)
    • Afgørelsestype: Afgørelse fra højesteret
    • Afgørelsesdato: 06/01/2012
    • Retsinstans: Højesteret
    • Emne:
    • Sagsøger: Danske Spil A/S (gaming operator)
    • Sagsøgt: Ladbrokes Betting and Gaming Ltd.(gaming operator)
    • Nøgleord: advertisement, comparative advertising, confusion, false impression, unfair competition
  • Direktivets artikler
    Unfair Commercial Practices Directive, Chapter 2, Section 1
  • Indledende note
    Discrediting a competitor can constitute a misleading commercial practice.
  • Fakta
    Both defendant and plaintiff are large gaming operators.

    From May to September 2008, the defendant carried on a publicity campaign using the word "Danske Spil" in a comparable commercial. More specifically, the defendant used the slogan "Danske spil, engelske odds" (Danske Spil (the plaintiff's name), English odds).

    Later, the plaintiff carried out a television marketing campaign using pictures which brought along negative associations with foreign games. For example, the campaign contained speak and not very flattering pictures of a Philippine bookmaker and a cigar-smoking general manger of a casino with associations to the Italian mafia.

    The defendant stated that the plaintiff tried to give the impression that foreign gaming operators deceive their players and use mafia methods.  
  • Juridisk spørgsmål
    Does discrediting a competitor, constitute a misleading commercial practice?
  • Afgørelse

    The Supreme Court decided that both the defendant's and the plaintiff’s publicity campaigns had violated Sections 1, 3 and 5 of the Danish Marketing Practices Act.

    The Court, however, ruled that neither the defendant nor the plaintiff were to pay compensation. This was mainly because the parties had violated the Danish Marketing Practices Act at the same gross level and since none of them had proven to have suffered a greater loss than the opponent.  

    Hele teksten: Hele teksten

  • Relaterede sager

    Ingen resultater

  • Retslitteratur

    Ingen resultater

  • Resultat
    The plaintiff's and the defendant's claims were partly denied, partly granted.